Throughout an entire playthrough you must refuse the Tarot card readings at the end of each chapter. It is recommended to pick up at least 1 tarot card in each chapter including the prologue to make sure you reject Eliza's See More prompt 10 times across a single playthrough.
You may still pick up the Tarot card "The Hierophant" in Chapter 9.
Credit to ThePugHybrid for their
guide.